| Winners | Year | Rating | Format Sort descending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dirck Bartlett | 1993 | class a | hardball |
| Dirck Bartlett | 1994 | class a | hardball |
| Tim Chisolm | 1995 | class a | hardball |
| Pat Miller | 1996 | class a | hardball |
| J. Styrt | 1964 | class b | hardball |
| J.S. Finney | 1965 | class b | hardball |
| H.M. Franklin | 1966 | class b | hardball |
| S.H. Schriver | 1967 | class b | hardball |
| A.C. Hubbard | 1968 | class b | hardball |
| J.A. Leutkemeyer | 1969 | class b | hardball |
| P. Parker | 1970 | class b | hardball |
| P.Wolff | 1971 | class b | hardball |
| W. Smyth | 1972 | class b | hardball |
| A.B. Martin | 1973 | class b | hardball |
| Jas. J. Lacy, III | 1974 | class b | hardball |
