| Winners | Year | Rating | Format Sort descending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jas. J. Lacy, Jr. | 1976 | veterans | hardball |
| E. F. O'Conor | 1977 | veterans | hardball |
| W. J. Rice | 1978 | veterans | hardball |
| E. F. O'Conor | 1979 | veterans | hardball |
| W. J. Rice | 1980 | veterans | hardball |
| E. F. O'Conor | 1981 | veterans | hardball |
| W. J. Rice | 1982 | veterans | hardball |
| W. J. Rice | 1983 | veterans | hardball |
| J. S. Finney | 1984 | veterans | hardball |
| T. J. Hense, Jr. | 1985 | veterans | hardball |
| T. J. Hense, Jr. | 1986 | veterans | hardball |
| T. J. Hense, Jr. | 1987 | veterans | hardball |
| A.B. Martin | 1988 | veterans | hardball |
| J. Zug | 1989 | veterans | hardball |
| J. Zug | 1990 | veterans | hardball |
