| Winners | Year | Rating Sort descending | Format |
|---|---|---|---|
| F. X. Wells | 1965 | class c | hardball |
| T. r. Dankmeyer | 1966 | class c | hardball |
| J. McWebster, Jr. | 1967 | class c | hardball |
| H. A. Ciccarone | 1968 | class c | hardball |
| H. H. Minan | 1969 | class c | hardball |
| T. W. Greene | 1970 | class c | hardball |
| S. H. Dorney, Jr | 1971 | class c | hardball |
| G.E. Boynton | 1972 | class c | hardball |
| S. S. Janney, III | 1973 | class c | hardball |
| P. H. Ellis | 1974 | class c | hardball |
| M. Talbott | 1975 | class c | hardball |
| P.H. Deitz | 1976 | class c | hardball |
| P. A. M. Miller | 1977 | class c | hardball |
| N. Childs | 1978 | class c | hardball |
| D. T. Warfield | 1979 | class c | hardball |
